U.S.–Canada Feud Takes a Toll on Vermont's Northeast Kingdom

  • Print

NEWPORT, Vt. — The border between Vermont and Québec has long been a source of economic opportunity. Canadian visitors cross into the Northeast Kingdom to shop, dine, and vacation, supporting businesses whose fortunes are closely tied to their northern neighbors.

But that familiar exchange is changing.

As tensions between Washington and Ottawa deepen, businesses in Newport are reporting fewer Canadian customers. State economic development officials say the consequences are extending beyond tourism, adding to the economic uncertainty already confronting Vermont.

The dispute has also brought an international dimension to the state's affordability debate, one of the central issues in the November elections. For communities along the Canadian border, decisions made in Washington are increasingly affecting local businesses.

 

Fewer Canadian Visitors in Newport

At the Eastside Restaurant, overlooking Lake Memphremagog, Canadian visitors have traditionally been an important part of the clientele. Some even arrive by boat.

Corey Holmes says fewer Canadians are coming.

The restaurant's boutique has seen Canadian customer traffic dwindle. Although some loyal customers still visit, the business has experienced a noticeable shift in cross-border shopping.

For Newport, the consequences extend beyond individual establishments. Restaurants, shops, and other businesses benefit from visitors who often combine shopping, dining, and recreation during their trips across the border.

The drop in Canadian traffic is disrupting a commercial relationship local businesses have relied on for years.

Economic Pressure Beyond Tourism

Tim Tierney, a Vermont economic development official, estimates that tourism in northern Vermont has declined by approximately 35 percent.

The effects are being felt across the region's hospitality, retail, and recreation sectors, including destinations in the Northeast Kingdom.

Tierney says uncertainty surrounding U.S.–Canada trade relations is also affecting business decisions.

"I think uncertainty has been the biggest impact we've seen because it's not good for businesses to have an uncertain future," he said.

Higher costs for construction materials and imported equipment are creating additional challenges for businesses considering investments or expansion.

Tierney says tariffs affect manufacturers and craftspeople who depend on materials purchased across the border. For some businesses, rising costs can make previously negotiated contracts impossible to fulfill or render them financially unviable.

For consumers, the economic consequences can mean higher prices and reduced business activity.

For a region already facing affordability challenges, the loss of Canadian spending and the disruption of established supply chains add further pressure.

Vermont and Québec: A Relationship Beyond Washington

In September, Vermont State Senator Martine Larocque-Gulick led a group of fellow senators and citizens to Montréal to express solidarity with their Canadian neighbors, as tensions between Washington and Ottawa threatened a relationship deeply rooted in Vermont's history and economy.

For Vermont, particularly the Northeast Kingdom, Canada is more than a trading partner. Québec is more than a neighbor. Vermont and Québec share a French-Canadian heritage, family connections, tourism, and cross-border commerce.

From Newport's restaurants and shops to the ski resorts and recreational businesses that attract Québec visitors, the relationship supports local livelihoods.

Larocque-Gulick's initiative aimed to reinforce those connections at a time when federal policies are creating division. It also reflected a broader reality: Vermont's relationship with Québec is sustained not only by governments but by generations of residents, businesses, and communities whose lives have been intertwined across the border.

Solidarity has its limits, though. Vermont can maintain dialogue, encourage Canadian visitors to return, and strengthen cooperation with Québec. It cannot reverse federal tariffs or resolve the trade dispute on its own.

That distinction has become increasingly consequential for the Northeast Kingdom, where businesses and their customers are feeling the economic fallout from decisions made in Washington.

A Historic Rupture Between Neighbors

Jeffrey Ayres, a professor of international relations at Saint Michael's College, believes the current dispute represents a fundamental shift in the relationship between the United States and Canada.

Ayres pointed to Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney's characterization of the deteriorating relationship.

"Mark Carney has come in and said, bluntly, this is a rupture between the two countries, between Canada and the United States," Ayres said.

He described the tensions as more than a temporary disagreement.

Since the Canada–U.S. Free Trade Agreement, which took effect in 1989, and the North American Free Trade Agreement, implemented in 1994, economic integration has helped shape relations between the two countries, reinforcing an increasingly interconnected North American economy.

Despite occasional political disagreements, trade and investment continued to bring the two countries closer.

Ayres believes that dynamic has changed.

"It's politics. It's politics that is driving the economics," he said.

The political dispute has discouraged some visitors from crossing the border and prompted Canadian leaders to reconsider their country's economic dependence on its southern neighbor.

Ayres also emphasized that cooperation between American states and Canadian provinces remains important.

Known as paradiplomacy, these relationships allow regional governments to maintain dialogue and pursue common interests even when their national governments disagree.

But such cooperation cannot override federal trade policy.

The Cost of a Fractured Relationship

For Newport businesses, the dispute is not simply an international disagreement. Its consequences show up in fewer customers, uncertain revenues, and higher costs.

The Northeast Kingdom's proximity to Québec has historically been an economic advantage, connecting Vermont businesses to Canadian consumers, suppliers, and visitors.

That advantage has become a source of vulnerability as the political relationship deteriorates.

Vermont lawmakers and citizens continue to work to preserve cross-border ties, demonstrating the strength of the relationship at the community level. But restoring confidence among Canadian visitors and businesses will require more than goodwill.

Vermont and Québec remain bound by geography, history, and shared economic interests. Their communities can keep cooperating, but Washington and Ottawa still control decisions on tariffs and national trade policy.

In the Northeast Kingdom, local businesses are already paying the price.